喜剧，讲一个男人通过装假胡子装扮成兄弟两个人，周旋于女友和未来岳父之间，因为岳父喜欢有胡子的人，认为有胡子的人成熟稳重。Ramprasad Dashrathprasad Sharma (Amol Palekar) is looking for a better paying job. He and his sister Ratna (Manju Singh) have no relatives or acquaintances except Dr. Kedar (David). Dr.Kedar tells him about Bhavani Shankar's (Utpal Dutt) firm known as Urmila Traders. Shankar is a weird man. He is a man of traditional values, hence he naturally hates youth wearing modern clothes. He is a sports fan, but thinks lowly of youth knowing anything about sports. But his most weird trait is hatred towards men without moustaches. He thinks that men without moustaches are characterless.Ramprasad has a moustache. He takes care of other problems by wearing kurta & feigning ignorance about sports. Bhavani hires him immediately. Ram is a hardworking guy, so Bhavani (& Ram) have no problems. However, Ram once takes leave by pretending that his mother (who died many years ago) has taken ill, and goes to watch a hockey match. Bhavani Shankar, who also attended the match, sees him there.The next day Bhavani summons Ramprasad to his office and asks him about the Hockey match. Remembering the plot of a movie a friend of his is shooting, Ram convinces Bhavani Shankar that he had seen his "moustache-less" identical twin Lucky (alias Lakshmanprasad Dashrathprasad Sharma) at the stadium.Bhavani Shankar buys his argument & feels bad about accusing him and decides to make amends by hiring Lucky to teach his daughter Urmila (Bindiya Goswami) music. Ramprasad reluctantly shaves his moustache to become Lucky and starts to teach music to Urmila. He is helped by his actor friend Deven Verma (playing himself).Now Urmila aka Urmi is the exact opposite of her father. She takes immediate liking to Lucky, while Ram is barely noticed by her. Bhavani notices this & gives Ram another job to tutor on the pretext of her exams. Meanwhile, Mrs. Srivastav (Dina Pathak), a socialite, is roped to play the part of Ram, "Lakshman" & Ratna's mother. Like Ram, she also ends up playing her own twin in front of Bhavani.Ram decides to tell Urmila the truth. Urmila tells him to tell the truth to Bhavani as well. Ram goes to Bhavani to tell the truth, but Bhavani sees Ram's moustache giving away. Bhavani exposes Ram, but ends up thinking that Lucky murdered Ram & impersonated him to marry Urmila.In a hilarious chase that follows, Bhavani ends up totalling a police jeep. The Senior Inspector (Om Prakash) mistakes him for a thug named Pascal D'Costa & is about to lock him up in the jail. Only when his Inspector identifies Bhavani Shankar by his real identity is he freed. By now, a harried Bhavani has developed hatred for twin as well.On coming home, he finds that Urmila & Lucky are married. He refuses to give them blessings, until Dr.Kedar comes to the scene & explains the whole situation. Now, Bhavani becomes even more furious, but on everybody's insistence, relents. The film ends with a family photo of Mrs.Srivastav, Ratna, Urmila, Ram, Dr.Kedar, Bhavani's sister Kalindi (Shubha Khote) & Bhavani (who is shown without moustache).
內容空洞，視聽也不夠華彩，作為一個A24粉我都看不下去了，很久沒給A24系的恐怖片打差評了，上一次這麼幹還是《皮囊之下》那部電影，這部也值得，不過它是名副其實的倒數第一。
西北有高楼，无乃杞梁妻。一弹再三叹，但伤知音稀。
后半段太匆忙了，忘记原著去看这个故事还是不错的（可能是因为我没看过别的雪国改电影吧），那种日式的“不说”处理得略显僵硬。
将原作中的虚无变夯实了，不容易懂的故事也变得通俗。驹子后半太耀眼，就像一团火，周围一切都暗淡了，为爱奋不顾身看着一点也不徒劳。雪景虽美，却还是不若川端康成的文字美。
剧情有点像寡淡的白开水，看得昏昏欲睡。奈绪+1星，三味线是真弹，人物塑造得太好了，成为艺妓前的单纯可爱和扮成艺妓时的成熟妩媚，面对行男与叶子的前后不同态度，奔向火场时的勇敢果断
这片大概是有戒色吧的投资吧，充分说明了万恶淫为首的道理，这幕后花絮看完了，希望也有机会看到《农夫的女儿们》的正片。
银河好像哗啦一声，向他的心坎上倾泻下来。差不多十五年了，始终记得这一句。片子倒是马马虎虎。
拍得很美很平淡，独白好多啊。奈绪是纯洁可爱的，推翻了我之前对她的印象。叶子的演员不太符合。最后是感动我的。
又要加入那么多自己的理解，又要老老实实按照原著拍，这不是徒劳吗
在这个宁静、深邃、遥远的，被冰雪覆盖的北国小村氛围中，人物的情感交织是剧情主线，从某种程度上，三个人相互之间的情感交融，有一点类似于《红楼梦》中贾宝玉，薛宝钗，林黛玉三个人的感情纠结，爱而不可得，得而不能爱，患得患失。
高桥一生和奈绪的选角都不太适合这类文学体裁，即便人物情绪浓烈也无法有代入感，散发出一股照章行事而非创作的感觉。前者没有文人气质，后者的台词有点棒读，演这类题材整体上功底都不太够。森田望智倒是相对较能融入这类题材的气质氛围。过量的旁白来推动剧情是一枚险棋，除非演员旁白功力特好加上编剧特别会写，才会有加乘效果。雪景很美。
恐怖片？进度条过半都没个恐怖氛围，最后也就几个血腥的场面。桃李年华花羡兮的题材挺好的，拍的太垃圾了。
益生菌和奈绪都是好演员，可不晓得为什么，在这样的故事里完全撑不住；尤其奈绪，跟和服姿天生八字不合。尽管这是个严格依照小说顺序做的剧本，却反而看得人愈发吃力，还不如做得跟肥皂剧一样，说不定更好看呢。
没看过原著，单就电影来说还挺好，奈绪很有风情，整体节奏和张力也不错
高桥的声音很适合读旁白。这部剧有文笔和奈绪的美就可以了。叶的演员相比之下就，对不起。奈绪真的好几个镜头让我想起我优在料理仙姬里的造型。好美。
高中看过书，但是半句话都不记得了……连书是谁送的都记不清了（。只记得助眠效果一流，看十分钟必困。今天发现，不怪文字，剧版也是一样的困。不过这拍得像两个女人的爱恨纠缠是我观看方式有问题吗？？另外想问一句，霓虹这泡面头潮流什么时候过？
看完剧的我天啊,带着看美的眼睛看它吧!命运之轮,角色有灵魂.太耀眼就可以以念念不忘.“徒劳”一词贯穿全剧
雪中的奈绪太美了太美了，益生菌这个嫖客演得……不大得劲儿。镜头很漂亮，奈绪的和服装扮更漂亮，漂亮到我都没关心旁白在念叨些啥。
卡司在线，布景、构图、氛围还是不错的，配乐与氛围相合；打光太僵硬，改编了但改编得太直白和浅薄，高桥与角色适配度一般，驹子视角优于岛村视角。川端康成对人物心理的描写落于纸上是细腻和寂寥，一旦改编成对话就显得刻意又矫情。
终于发现奈绪和优酱长得像这回事儿了，想想优酱很适合这个角色，和一生君之前也合作过哈哈哈，奇怪的CP又嗑起来了。当然奈绪也很漂亮，本来就是冲着卡司看这部的，或许森田望智以后能接一些更符合她气质的本子吗，还是说黑木香这个角色实在太惊艳了。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
